Alien Muslims become vote banks fo CPIM and Indian citizenships in West Bengal
Sunilpal@aol.com to mabdulla51, me

Mr Palash Chandra Biswas has forwarded your comments on the above to me. You have rewritten history in your own style using vulgar and abusive words with regard to the communal persecution of our family. You have brought even uprooted "Emperor Babar built Masjid".(Incidentally Babar did not build any Masjid.There is a lot of hypocrisy and double standards on the Ayodhya structure. Please read "Unholy War, Time, 21 Dec. 1992,page 36-41 and also my letter in Bengali Weekly DESH published from Kolkata on 27 Feb 1993, page 11+ I). I however wonder why you have been so thin on the history of Bangladesh when 3 million Muslims and Hindus were butchered by Punjabi Muslim military in 1970-71 (genocide by the Pakistani Muslim military) and imprisoned Sheikh Mujibar Rahaman whom around 50% of Bangladeshi Muslims prefers to call as "father of Bangladesh" in preference to "MA Jinnah". The same Bengali Muslims of East Pakistan adored Jinnah also as father of Pakistan. Strange, is not it? My up brining and education cannot match your distortion, vulgarism and libellous statements.

However at the penultimate paragraph of your comments, you say you have "posed questions" to me which I "must ponder to find legitimate answer". Hence this e.mail.

I have given detailed account of the fact which is unalloyed truth. You have distorted the truth on which you have no direct knowledge. For example, how do you know that "Ismael Sheikh or Ashraf Gaen is nothing but Indian citizen". They voluntarily accepted Pakistani/Bangladeshi citizenships; The records of Pakistani and Bangladesh governments in Kushtia will prove this. Ismael's daughter "Sikha" was born, educated and "happily" married in Bangladesh but Ismael Sheikh lives in India's Shondanga. Ashraf Gaen's father Abhilash worked in Pakistani government in Kushtia and died there. Ashraf Gaen worked in Chuadanga Co-operative Corporation in Kushtia District but now lives in Shondanga. How do you consider them Indian citizens legally? According to Indian constitution, they are illegally settled aliens.

With regard to your confusion on Ekat/Haru Sheikh's "loyalty" to our family, simply the "loyalty" is due to our acceptance of pluralism unlike "other Muslims" who are antagonistic to them because they do not believe in pluralism. However if you believe in pluralism and sympathetic to this family you should look for answer from Mr Buddhadev Bhattacharya, Chief Minister of West Bengal, Writer's Building, Kolkata 700001, India, Fax. 033 2214 5480,phone: 033 2214 5555 e.mail:cm@wb.gov.in about the fabricated case against this family. The case no.: Dhubulia PS FIR 101/02 of 28.9.02, GR1584/02,Charge Sheet no. 114/02 30.10.02(State vs Ekat Ali Sheikh and others) as to why at the behest of his party a Hindu police officer made out a false case with false witnesses to cover up the assault of his sister- in- law Ainur Bibi on 28th September 2002.

Illegally constructed mosque is on the public road at Natun para of Shondanga. All secular Muslims in that area will tell you how a public pond and public road were occupied to construct a mosque. The ruling CPIM party turns a blind eye to preserve vote banks of the Muslims who do not believe in pluralism.

With regard to our inciting communal riots, it is established fact that communal riots take place in the areas where both the Muslims and Hindus are nearly equally divided and when the Muslims do not want to accept pluralism and still show solidarity with Pakistan and or Bangladesh. Wherever one religious group is majority compared with the other, the numerically minority group suffers silently like the Hindus in Bangladesh and in our village. This will continue unless people are educated that religion is a private matter and should not bind the people together. The reason for genocide in Bangla Desh has been largely forgotten but the Hindu-Muslim local skirmishes in India or a demolition of a disused structure in Ayodhya cause more concern to you and others. Why the genocide is less important when you rewrite history?

I could go on to show the contradiction in your theocratic thoughts.

However I would like to clarify your confusion on the issues which I wrote to Mr Biswas and shall answer your other questions if you itemise those properly.

I am amazed that you have asked me and Mr Biswas "to refrain from the Bangladesh websites". Why? It appears that you seem to think that you control Bangladesh websites.Please note that I have very little time to see Bangladesh website and rarely see it when someone advises me to look at it.
Sunil Kumar Pal
Chartered Electrical Engineer
70 Mary Green
London NW8 0BS

PS Why don't you give your proper e.mail and address like Mr Biswas and me?